Puffy VS Keetsa Mattress Comparison (2023)

Are you looking for a new mattress, but can’t decide between a Puffy and Keetsa? You’ve come to the right place.

We’ll compare these two mattresses side-by-side so you can make an informed decision about which one is best for you. We’ll look at both the similarities and differences between them, as well as their respective construction, features and price points.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a comprehensive understanding of these two mattresses and know which one is best suited to your needs. So if you’re ready to start your journey towards restful sleep, let’s begin.

Puffy Mattress Overview

Puffy is a popular mattress brand that has been around since 2017. It features a unique design and materials that make it stand out in the mattress market.

The mattress is constructed with three layers of foam, including two layers of supportive memory foam and one layer of cooling gel-infused foam. This construction provides great contouring pressure relief while still offering plenty of support. It’s also designed to be incredibly responsive, which helps keep sleepers cool throughout the night.

Additionally, Puffy offers a 101-night trial period and a lifetime warranty, so customers can sleep with confidence knowing they are covered should anything happen to their mattress. All in all, Puffy is an excellent choice for those looking for a supportive yet plush sleeping experience.

See our latest review of Puffy mattress.

Keetsa Mattress Overview

Keetsa is a company that specializes in eco-friendly mattresses. Their products are made from natural materials, such as organic cotton, bamboo and recycled steel coils. They offer several different types of mattresses, including memory foam, latex and hybrid models. All of their mattresses come with a 10 year warranty and are designed to be comfortable and supportive while also being environmentally friendly.

The Keetsa mattress is designed to provide superior support and comfort without sacrificing quality or sustainability. It has a unique design that includes contouring layers of memory foam to provide pressure relief and support for the spine, neck and shoulders. The mattress also features an innovative cooling system that helps regulate body temperature so you can sleep more comfortably throughout the night.

Keetsa offers free shipping on all orders, as well as free returns within 30 days if you’re not satisfied with your purchase. They also have a 100-night risk-free trial so you can experience the mattress before committing to it long-term. With a commitment to customer service and eco-friendly materials, Keetsa is an excellent choice for anyone looking for an eco-friendly mattress that provides comfort and support at an affordable price.

puffy vs keetsa mattress comparison
Puffy mattress vs Keetsa mattress comparison. Which mattress is better?

Materials And Construction

The Puffy mattress is made up of a three-layer construction, consisting of a top layer of cooling cloud foam, a middle layer of climate adaptive foam and a base layer of durable high-density foam.

The top layer is designed to provide comfort and support while the middle layer helps regulate temperature to keep you cool. The bottom layer provides extra support and durability.

The Keetsa mattress is constructed with four layers of material that provide comfort and support. The top two layers are made up of breathable BioFoam which regulates body temperature and provides support, while the second two layers are comprised of supportive coils that give the mattress its shape and bounce.

Both mattresses offer great levels of comfort, support, durability and temperature regulation through their respective constructions.

Comfort & Support

When it comes to comfort and support, Puffy and Keetsa both provide high-quality mattresses. Puffy’s mattress is made up of three layers of adaptive foam and cooling gel foam, while Keetsa’s mattress has five layers including individually pocketed coils. Both mattresses are designed to provide the highest level of comfort and support for those who sleep on them.

The top layer of Puffy’s mattress is designed to contour around your body, providing pressure relief and comfort. The second and third layers are made from dense foam, offering superior support for the entire body. The cooling gel foam helps regulate temperature so that you don’t overheat at night.

Keetsa’s mattress features a top layer of medium-soft memory foam that contours around your body for pressure relief. Its second layer provides a base for the other layers, followed by individual pocketed coils that offer superior support throughout the night. Beneath the pocketed coils is another layer of soft memory foam that helps to reduce motion transfer between partners. Finally, a breathable base layer helps keep air circulating beneath you while you sleep.

Overall, both mattresses provide comfort and support that make them ideal choices for anyone looking for a great night’s sleep. They both offer different levels of firmness, making them suitable for people with different sleeping styles and preferences.

Firmness & Feel

When it comes to firmness and feel, the Puffy mattress has a medium-firm profile that is designed to be comfortable for all sleeping positions. The mattress features a layer of foam that contours to the body, allowing for pressure relief. It also contains a layer of cooling foam that helps keep sleepers cool and comfortable throughout the night.

On the other hand, the Keetsa mattress offers two different firmness levels – medium-firm and plush. The mattress features an extra-thick comfort layer that provides pressure relief while still being supportive. Additionally, it contains an innovative coil system that helps with motion isolation and support.

When it comes to overall feel, both mattresses are designed to provide a comfortable sleeping experience. The Puffy mattress has a soft and responsive surface, while the Keetsa mattress is slightly firmer but still provides comfort and pressure relief. Both mattresses can help with motion isolation so couples don’t disturb each other when they move in bed.

Ultimately, choosing between these two mattresses will come down to personal preference based on desired firmness level and overall sleep experience.

Temperature Regulation

When it comes to temperature regulation, both the Puffy and Keetsa mattresses offer a great deal of comfort.

The Puffy mattress is constructed with cooling foam layers that are designed to keep the sleeper cool throughout the night. Additionally, the mattress’ temperature regulating fabric cover helps wick away heat and moisture, providing a comfortable sleeping environment.

On the other hand, Keetsa also offers temperature regulation with its multiple layers of air-flow foam and breathable layers of memory foam. The mattress also includes a cooling gel layer that helps to dissipate heat and keep the sleeper cool all night long.

In terms of overall comfort and temperature control, both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses provide excellent support for sleepers. Both mattresses feature quality materials that are designed to provide maximum comfort and temperature regulation for an optimal sleep experience. However, Puffy’s cooling foam layers and fabric cover may give it an edge over Keetsa in terms of temperature control capabilities.

Ultimately, both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses offer great options for those looking for temperature regulation when choosing their mattress. With their respective features designed to help keep sleepers cool throughout the night, either one could be a great choice depending on individual preferences.

Edge Support

Moving on from temperature regulation, we’ll now look at the edge support of both the Puffy and Keetsa mattresses. Generally speaking, the Puffy mattress offers superior edge support due to its special foam construction. This unique foam is designed to provide a firm base along with enhanced stability when sleeping near or on the edge of the mattress. Additionally, this foam is also very responsive, so it helps reduce any motion transfer you may experience when someone else moves around on the other side of the bed.

On the other hand, Keetsa’s mattress offers minimal edge support. This is because its comfort layers are made from memory foam and innersprings instead of special foam. As a result, if you sleep near or on the edge of this mattress it could cause you to feel like you’re sinking in or rolling off due to lack of firmness and stability.

When it comes to edge support for these two mattresses, there’s a clear winner: The Puffy mattress provides superior edge support compared to Keetsa’s mattress due to its special foam construction which offers enhanced stability and responsiveness.

Motion Isolation

When it comes to motion isolation, both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses have their advantages.

Puffy is a foam mattress, which is known for its exceptional motion isolation. Its two layers of foam help absorb movement so that when one person moves around or gets up, the other won’t feel any disturbance. On the other hand, Keetsa’s hybrid construction provides some excellent motion isolation thanks to its pocketed coils. They are designed to reduce the transfer of motion from one side of the bed to another.

In terms of edge support, Puffy has an edge over Keetsa. Its all-foam construction makes it easier for people who might need more support when sitting or sleeping near the edges. The combination of comfort and support layers in Keetsa helps provide better edge support than most all-foam mattresses but not as much as Puffy.

Overall, while both mattresses offer good motion isolation and edge support, Puffy has a slight advantage in terms of providing more consistent firmness across the entire surface of the mattress and superior edge support.

Price Comparison

Moving on from motion isolation, let’s compare the prices between Puffy and Keetsa mattresses. When it comes to cost, Puffy has the upper hand. Their mattress starts at $795 for a twin size, while Keetsa’s mattress starts at $899 for a twin size. This gives Puffy a slight edge in terms of affordability.

In addition to the base price, both companies offer deals and promotions to their customers. Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial with free shipping and returns as well as a lifetime warranty. On the other hand, Keetsa offers a 25-year limited warranty and an additional 5-year non-prorated warranty on all purchases made through their website.

When considering price, Puffy is the more affordable option compared to Keetsa. However, Keetsa’s extended warranties may be worth considering when making your decision on which mattress to purchase.

Pressure Relief

Puffy and Keetsa mattresses have different levels of pressure relief. Puffy’s top layer is made of memory foam, providing excellent contouring. This helps relieve pressure on the body and reduce aches and pains.

Meanwhile, Keetsa’s mattress has a unique 100% natural bamboo charcoal layer that works to absorb heat and distribute weight evenly. This also helps to reduce pressure points while offering superior support.

When it comes to motion transfer, both mattresses perform well. The individual layers in the Puffy mattress help isolate motion while its foam core minimizes disturbance due to movement or getting in and out of bed. On the other hand, Keetsa’s mattress contains coils that offer superior motion isolation, allowing for undisturbed sleep even if your partner moves around in their sleep.

Ultimately, both mattresses provide excellent pressure relief as well as good motion transfer capability. They are ideal for people who suffer from chronic pain or who share their bed with a partner who tends to toss and turn at night. With either one of these mattresses, you can expect restful sleep without worrying about being disturbed by your partner’s movements or discomfort from soreness or stiffness caused by poor pressure relief.

Warranty & Return Policy

When it comes to warranty and return policy, Puffy and Keetsa offer two very different options. Puffy provides a lifetime warranty on their mattresses, meaning that any defects or damages that occur during the lifetime of the mattress are covered by the manufacturer.

In addition, Puffy also offers a 101-night trial period for customers to test out their mattress before making a final purchase decision. On the other hand, Keetsa does not provide a lifetime warranty but does offer an extended 5-year limited warranty on its mattresses. Customers can also take advantage of Keetsa’s 30-day sleep trial to make sure they’re satisfied with their purchase before committing to it long term.

When it comes to returns and refunds, both companies have similar policies in place. Customers who are not satisfied with their purchase can return or exchange the mattress within the first 101 nights (for Puffy) or 30 days (for Keetsa). Both companies will issue full refunds for returns made within these time periods. After this period has elapsed, however, neither company offers refunds but may provide store credit or exchanges depending on the situation.

Overall, Puffy and Keetsa offer two distinct approaches when it comes to warranty and return policy that cater to different types of customers with varied needs. It’s important to consider each company’s policies carefully before making a final purchasing decision so that you find one that fits your particular situation best.

Delivery, Setup And Returns

When it comes to delivery, setup, and returns, Puffy and Keetsa offer similar services. Both companies provide free shipping on all orders within the continental United States.

In terms of setup, Puffy provides a 100-night trial that allows customers to try out their mattress before deciding if they want to keep it. If not, they can return the product with no questions asked. Keetsa also offers a trial period of 90 nights, but if customers decide to return their mattress after this period they are subject to a 20% restocking fee.

Both companies offer professional white-glove delivery and setup services for an additional fee. White-glove delivery includes in-home delivery and removal of old mattresses as well as complete assembly and setup of the new product. The cost for this service varies by company but is typically between $99-$149 depending on location.

In summary, when it comes to delivery, setup and returns both Puffy and Keetsa offer similar services with slight differences in terms of trial periods and return fees. Customers should carefully consider which option best meets their needs before making a purchase decision.

Customer Service

To get a better idea of the customer service experiences between Puffy and Keetsa, let’s take a closer look.

Puffy offers an excellent customer service experience with their Sleep Concierge team available 24/7 for any questions or concerns. They also have an online help desk for ordering and delivery issues as well as warranty information. Keetsa also provides good customer service, with their customer care team available 24/7 to answer any questions. They also offer an online help desk that can assist customers with ordering, delivery and warranty issues.

Overall, both Puffy and Keetsa offer great customer service experiences. Puffy has the advantage of having a dedicated Sleep Concierge team while Keetsa has a more general customer care team that is available 24/7.

However, both companies provide helpful online help desks that can assist customers with any questions or issues they may have regarding their purchase. In the end, it comes down to personal preference when choosing which company offers the best overall customer service experience for you.

Pros Vs Cons

When comparing the Puffy mattress to the Keetsa mattress, there are pros and cons to both. In terms of comfort, the Puffy mattress is a medium-firm option that contours to the body for pressure relief and support.

It has a layer of cooling gel foam on top for temperature regulation, and it’s also covered in a thick layer of foam that adds extra cushioning. On the other hand, the Keetsa mattress is a medium-soft option with layers of memory foam that provide great support and comfort. However, it lacks temperature regulation features.

In terms of durability, both mattresses have been tested for longevity and quality assurance. The Puffy mattress is made with high-quality materials such as CertiPUR-US certified foam and cooling gel foam which ensures its durability over time. The Keetsa mattress is constructed with multiple layers of foam which makes it very durable even after years of use.

The price point between these two mattresses varies depending on size and model chosen. The Puffy mattress costs around $900 while the Keetsa mattress ranges from $400 to $1,000 depending on size. Both mattresses come with generous trial periods to ensure customer satisfaction before purchase. Ultimately, buyers must weigh their preferences when choosing between these two mattresses since they both offer different levels of comfort, durability, and affordability.

Final Verdict

The Puffy and Keetsa mattresses have many similarities and differences. Both mattresses are good quality and offer a range of features that will help to ensure a comfortable sleep. However, the Keetsa mattress is more expensive than the Puffy mattress, which may make it difficult for some people to afford.

When it comes to comfort, the Puffy mattress is considered to be more supportive, while the Keetsa mattress has a softer feel. In terms of motion transfer, the Puffy mattress does a better job at minimizing movement, while the Keetsa mattress offers slightly more bounce. Additionally, both mattresses come with warranties that cover any manufacturing defects.

Overall, both mattresses have their pros and cons. The Puffy mattress is more affordable and provides better support, while the Keetsa mattress has a softer feel and offers slightly more bounce. Therefore, it’s important for consumers to consider their needs when deciding between these two options.

Is Puffy Mattress Better Than Keetsa Mattress?

The Puffy mattress and the Keetsa mattress both offer their own unique benefits. The Puffy mattress is constructed with high-end materials that provide excellent comfort and support, while the Keetsa mattress is more affordable and offers a firmer feel. In terms of delivery, setup and returns, both companies offer similar services so the decision will come down to individual preference.

When it comes to customer service, Puffy’s reps are incredibly helpful and knowledgeable, whereas Keetsa’s customer service can be slow to respond. Ultimately, both mattresses have their pros and cons which make them suitable for different types of sleepers.

If you’re looking for a luxury mattress that offers comfort and support without breaking the bank, then the Puffy is definitely worth considering. On the other hand, if you’re looking for an affordable option that provides good support without too much cushioning, then the Keetsa could be your best bet.

At the end of the day, it all comes down to personal preference when deciding between these two mattresses. Both offer great value for money and are sure to provide great sleep experiences for years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Puffy and Keetsa mattresses?

Puffy mattresses are made from high-density foam layers, while Keetsa mattresses use different materials such as memory foam, latex, and pocketed coils. Puffy offers a range of firmness options, while Keetsa has a limited range of firmness levels.

Which mattress is better for back pain relief, Puffy or Keetsa?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses offer excellent support for back pain relief. However, Puffy mattresses are more suitable for people who prefer a softer feel, while Keetsa mattresses are firmer and more supportive.

Are Puffy mattresses good for side sleepers?

Yes, Puffy mattresses are an excellent choice for side sleepers. The soft foam layers provide excellent pressure relief for the hips and shoulders, making it easier to sleep in a comfortable position.

Can I try Puffy or Keetsa mattresses before I buy them?

Both Puffy and Keetsa offer a 101-night sleep trial period, during which you can try the mattress in the comfort of your own home. If you’re not satisfied with the mattress, you can return it for a full refund.

Which mattress is more durable, Puffy or Keetsa?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses are designed to last for several years. Puffy mattresses are made from high-quality materials that are resistant to wear and tear, while Keetsa mattresses are made from eco-friendly materials that are durable and long-lasting.

How long does it take for Puffy or Keetsa mattresses to fully expand?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses should expand to their full size within 24-48 hours of being unboxed. However, it’s recommended to wait 48 hours before using the mattress to allow it to fully expand and air out.

Do Puffy and Keetsa mattresses have a strong odor?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses may have a slight odor when they are first unboxed. However, the odor should dissipate within a few hours or days as the mattress airs out.

Which mattress has better motion isolation, Puffy or Keetsa?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses offer excellent motion isolation, making them a good choice for couples who don’t want to disturb each other’s sleep. However, Puffy mattresses are better at isolating motion than Keetsa mattresses.

How do I clean and maintain my Puffy or Keetsa mattress?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses come with removable covers that can be washed in the washing machine. To maintain the mattress, it’s recommended to rotate it every few months to prevent sagging.

Which mattress is better value for money, Puffy or Keetsa?

Both Puffy and Keetsa mattresses are priced competitively and offer good value for money. Puffy mattresses are slightly more expensive than Keetsa mattresses, but they also offer more features and options to choose from.

About Perry Morris

Perry Morris is a freelance writer, columnist, and mattress expert who contributes content for online publications such as New Mattress Time.