Puffy VS Allswell Mattress Comparison (2023)

Are you looking for the perfect mattress to give you a good night’s sleep? The Puffy and Allswell mattresses have become two of the most popular choices, but which one is right for you? We’ll compare the Puffy and Allswell mattresses side-by-side so that you can make an informed decision.

The Puffy mattress is made with high-quality materials, such as CertiPUR-US certified foam and cooling Cloud Gel, so it provides superior comfort and support. It also has a lifetime warranty and free shipping, making it accessible to anyone who wants to purchase it.

On the other hand, the Allswell mattress is designed with temperature-regulating wool fabric and individually pocketed coils to provide extra support while maintaining a cool temperature. Plus, it has a 100-night trial period that allows you to test out the mattress without any risk.

We’ll take a closer look at each of these mattresses to see what makes them unique. We’ll discuss their construction, comfort level, price range, warranties and more in order to determine which one is right for you. So let’s get started.

Don’t forget to check out our latest Puffy mattress review.


Puffy and Allswell are two mattress companies offering a variety of models to meet different sleep needs. Each brand offers distinct features such as firmness, quality of materials, and cooling technologies. This comparison will take a closer look at the differences between Puffy and Allswell mattresses so that you can make an informed decision when shopping for the perfect mattress.

When comparing Puffy vs Allswell mattresses, it’s important to consider the construction, comfort layers, motion isolation, edge support, temperature neutrality, and pricing. Puffy mattresses have an all-foam construction with a medium-firm feel. They provide excellent pressure relief and contouring along with great motion isolation.

The top layer of their mattresses is made from specialized foam that helps keep them cooler than traditional memory foam beds. Allswell mattresses also feature all-foam construction but offer a slightly firmer feel than Puffy beds. They provide good pressure relief but not quite as much as Puffy beds do. Allswell mattresses are also designed with cooling technologies in mind to help keep you comfortable while sleeping.

Overall, both brands offer great options for those looking for comfortable foam beds. The main difference between them is in their feel—Puffy has a softer option while Allswell has a slightly firmer one—as well as slight variations in temperature neutrality and motion isolation capabilities. It’s important to consider your individual preferences before deciding which mattress is right for you.

Construction & Materials

The construction and materials of both the Puffy and Allswell mattresses are standard for a foam mattress. The Puffy mattress is composed of three layers: 2” of cooling Cloud Foam, 2” of Comfort Foam, and 6” of high-density support foam. It also features a cover made from an innovative material called Puffy Lux. This is a blend of viscose and polyester that helps keep you cool during the night.

The Allswell mattress has two layers: 1.5” layer of comfort foam and 7.5” layer of high-density support foam with a quilted stretch-knit cover made up of polyester, spandex, and rayon blend fabric. The cover is designed to provide temperature regulation while being soft to the touch.

Both mattresses have similar construction materials but there are subtle differences in the cover materials which could affect sleeping comfort. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide which one best fits your needs.

puffy vs allswell mattress comparison
Is Puffy mattress vs Allswell mattress

Firmness & Support

The Puffy mattress is known for its medium-firm feel, while the Allswell mattress has a firmer feel. The Puffy mattress is made of three layers of foam, including a memory foam layer that’s designed to contour to your body and provide support.

The Allswell mattress is made with a combination of foam layers, including a high-density foam base layer that gives it more support and firmness than the Puffy. Both mattresses have excellent motion isolation capabilities, so you won’t be disturbed by movement from your partner or pet during sleep.

When it comes to edge support, the Allswell mattress provides better edge support than the Puffy mattress. This means you can sit on the edge of the bed without feeling like you’re going to roll off. The Puffy does offer some edge support but it’s not as good as what you get with the Allswell.

In terms of overall comfort and support, both mattresses are great options for different types of sleepers. The Puffy may be best suited for side sleepers who need extra pressure relief, while the Allswell may be better suited for those who need more firmness and stability in their bed. Ultimately, choosing between these two mattresses will come down to personal preference and what type of sleeper you are.

Temperature Regulation

Moving on to temperature regulation, let’s compare the Puffy and Allswell mattresses. The Puffy mattress is designed with a cooling system that wicks away moisture and heat while you sleep.

Its layer of cooling foam helps keep your body cool while you rest. In contrast, the Allswell mattress has four layers of foam that provide good cushioning and comfort but can trap in heat if you tend to get too hot during the night. Though both mattresses offer some cooling features, the Puffy mattress does it more effectively.

The other factor to consider when comparing these two mattresses is their breathability. The Puffy mattress has an open-cell structure that allows air to flow freely through its layers, making it highly breathable and helping regulate body temperature during sleep. On the other hand, the Allswell mattress does not have as much airflow due to its high density foams, which can cause it to retain heat more easily than the Puffy mattress.

In summary, both mattresses have their advantages when it comes to temperature regulation but the Puffy mattress stands out as offering better breathability and cooling features than the Allswell mattress.

Motion Isolation

The Puffy mattress is designed with a combination of advanced foams that help to absorb motion. This helps to prevent disturbance from one sleeper to another, making it ideal for couples or people who often share their bed. The Allswell mattress also features foam layers that are designed to limit motion transfer, helping to reduce the amount of disturbance felt by one partner when the other shifts in bed.

In addition, both mattresses feature edge support systems that allow sleepers to feel secure even when they lie near the edge of the bed. The Puffy mattress has a layer of high-density foam along the perimeter, while Allswell’s mattress includes a reinforced perimeter support system made with individually encased coils. This gives each side of the bed increased stability and minimizes sinking near the edges.

Overall, both mattresses provide good motion isolation that helps ensure undisturbed sleep for all sleepers. Both beds offer a full range of comfort and support features so users can rest easy.

Edge Support

When it comes to edge support, both the Puffy and the Allswell mattresses offer excellent support. The Puffy mattress features a 2-inch high-density foam layer that provides extra firmness around the edges.

This helps to prevent sinking and gives the sleeper more support for sitting up or getting in and out of bed. The Allswell mattress also has a 1-inch edge support foam that provides added stability around the perimeter of the mattress. This edge support ensures that sleepers won’t feel like they’re going to roll off when they’re lying near the edge of the bed.

The overall edge support offered by both mattresses is strong enough to provide adequate stability while sleeping near the edges. However, some may find that their body weight causes them to sink more when they are sleeping at or near the perimeter of either bed.

In terms of edge support, both mattresses provide good stability but may not be suitable for those who prefer a firmer surface at or near the edges of their bed.

Price Range

When it comes to price range, there’s a clear distinction between Puffy and Allswell mattresses. Puffy is on the more affordable side, ranging from $600-$1,400 depending on the size of the mattress and any added accessories. Meanwhile, Allswell mattresses are pricier, with prices ranging from $375-2,000 for their mattresses.

The two companies also offer different financing options. With Puffy, you can finance your mattress over a period of time with no interest or credit check required. Allswell offers financing through Affirm with 0% APR for 3 or 6 months depending on the purchase amount.

When it comes to price range and financing options, Puffy and Allswell both offer some great deals that help make their products more accessible. However, the cost of each product differs significantly which may be an important factor when choosing between them.

puffy mattress
Puffy mattress

Trial Period & Warranty

When comparing Puffy and Allswell mattresses, both offer a 100-night sleep trial period. This gives customers ample time to determine whether the mattress is right for them or not. Both companies also provide a 10-year warranty, which covers defects in the material and construction of the mattress.

The Puffy warranty covers any physical flaws that may appear over time such as sagging or body impressions deeper than one inch. The Allswell warranty also covers similar physical flaws, but it does not cover normal wear and tear due to age or abuse.

Both companies offer a money-back guarantee if customers are unhappy with their product during the trial period. That said, customers should be sure to read through each company’s terms and conditions before making their purchase in order to ensure that they understand all of their rights and obligations regarding returns.

Shipping, Delivery & Setup

The trial period and warranty comparison between Puffy and Allswell mattresses is now complete. Moving on, let’s take a look at the shipping, delivery, and setup options available with each mattress.

Puffy offers free shipping throughout the United States, as well as complimentary White Glove Delivery in select areas. If you choose this delivery option, a team will bring your mattress to your home and set it up in the desired location for you. Puffy also offers free returns within 101 days of purchase if you’re not satisfied with your purchase.

Allswell also offers free standard shipping in the U.S., but does not have an option for White Glove Delivery or free returns. Instead, Allswell provides helpful video tutorials that show you how to properly unpack and set up your mattress yourself.

Overall, both companies make it easy for their customers to receive their mattresses quickly and easily. While Puffy provides added convenience with its White Glove Delivery option and complimentary returns policy, Allswell provides helpful guidance through its instructional videos so customers can set up their own mattresses without assistance.

Customer Service

When comparing the customer service of Puffy and Allswell mattresses, it’s important to consider both companies’ policies regarding returns and warranties. Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial for customers who purchase their mattress, giving them time to decide if the mattress is right for them.

If they decide it isn’t, they can return it for a full refund. The company also offers a lifetime warranty. Allswell provides a 100-night sleep trial period and allows customers to return their mattress during this period for a full refund. They offer two different warranties: one that covers defects in workmanship and materials, and one that covers sagging of greater than 1 inch.

When considering customer service features, both companies provide excellent options that are beneficial to buyers. Puffy’s 101-night sleep trial gives customers more time to test out the product without commitment while still being able to return it if unsatisfied, whereas Allswell’s two different warranties provide extra protection against potential defects or sagging in the future which gives customers peace of mind when making their purchase decision.

In terms of customer service benefits, both companies offer excellent options that give buyers confidence when buying their new mattress.

Sleep Experience

Moving on from customer service, let’s look at how the Puffy and Allswell mattress compare in terms of sleep experience. Firstly, both mattresses offer a medium-firm feel that’s suitable for most sleepers. The Puffy mattress is slightly plusher than the Allswell mattress and also has better edge support, which makes it a great option for couples who share the bed. It also has excellent motion isolation, so you won’t be disturbed if your partner gets up in the night.

The Allswell mattress is firmer than the Puffy mattress and offers plenty of support for all body types. It also has great temperature regulation so you won’t overheat during the night. Both mattresses are made with breathable materials that ensure proper ventilation. This helps to keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night.

Overall, both Puffy and Allswell mattresses offer an enjoyable sleep experience for most people. They’re both supportive, comfortable, and provide excellent cooling properties. With either one of these mattresses, you’ll be sure to get a good night’s rest.

Pros And Cons

Both the Puffy and Allswell mattresses are great options for those looking for a comfortable sleep experience. However, there are pros and cons to both that should be considered before making a purchase.

The Puffy mattress is made of a combination of memory foam and polyfoam layers, which makes it extremely comfortable. It also has cooling gel foam technology that helps regulate temperature throughout the night. Additionally, the Puffy mattress is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning it meets all safety standards. On the other hand, some may find that its lack of edge support make it less suitable for couples who share a bed.

The Allswell mattress offers great value for its price point, with many features usually found in more expensive mattresses. The top layer is composed of AirTek foam designed to reduce motion transfer and provide pressure relief. Plus, the Allswell mattress is CertiPUR-US certified and comes with a 10-year warranty. The downside is that it has fewer layers than some competitors and may not provide as much comfort or support as other options on the market.

When choosing between these two mattresses, buyers must weigh their own needs against the pros and cons to determine which one will work best for them. It’s important to compare prices so you can get a good deal without sacrificing quality or comfort.

Who Should Buy It?

When it comes to deciding between a Puffy and an Allswell mattress, the best choice really depends on the individual’s needs. Those who want a firmer mattress should opt for the Allswell, while those looking for something softer should go with the Puffy. Both mattresses also offer great support for back and stomach sleepers.

The Puffy mattress is ideal for those who suffer from back pain or need more pressure relief due to its three layers of foam that conform to the body. Its softness also makes it great for side sleepers who want to reduce shoulder and hip pressure. Additionally, its cooling technology helps keep you comfortable throughout the night.

On the other hand, the Allswell mattress is great for those who need extra support due to its hybrid construction and pocketed coils. It also provides good motion isolation, making it a great option for couples who might otherwise be disturbed by their partner’s movements during sleep.

Overall, both mattresses are excellent options depending on your specific needs and preferences. With a range of features to choose from, there’s sure to be one that’s perfect for you.

Alternatives To Consider

When it comes to choosing a mattress, both the Puffy and Allswell mattresses are great options. However, there are other alternatives to consider.

One option is Casper Mattress, which offers a variety of features that make it stand out from the crowd. It has an innovative foam design that provides excellent support and comfort while also being breathable and cooling. It also has a hybrid design that combines two layers of foam with supportive coils for added comfort and pressure relief.

Another option is Avocado Mattress, which is designed with eco-friendly materials such as natural latex, organic wool and cotton for superior comfort without sacrificing breathability or support. Avocado’s Green-Sleep technology promotes healthy sleep habits by using plant-based foams to reduce motion transfer and keep you cool at night.

Finally, Tuft & Needle Mattress is another alternative to consider if you’re looking for a comfortable yet affordable mattress. It has adaptive foam layers that provide superior support while also offering cooling properties for improved temperature regulation and better sleep quality overall.

Final Recommendation

Having looked at the features of both the Puffy and Allswell mattresses, it’s time to decide which one is right for you. Ultimately, this is a personal decision that depends on your individual sleeping preferences and needs. Both mattresses have many appealing qualities – but they also have some trade-offs.

The Puffy mattress has a soft feel that may appeal to side sleepers or those who want more pressure relief. It also has an innovative cooling system, making it a good choice for hot sleepers. On the downside, its durability may be an issue since it’s only 10 inches thick and has 2 layers of foam.

Allswell is a great option for those looking for a firmer mattress with more support. It also has 3 layers of foam, giving it extra durability compared to Puffy. However, if you’re looking for something softer and bouncier than Allswell isn’t the best option since it’s quite firm.

It really comes down to what kind of support and feel you prefer in a mattress. Both Puffy and Allswell offer quality construction and comfort – so whichever one you choose should serve you well for years to come.

Is Puffy Mattress better than Allswell Mattress?

The Puffy and Allswell mattresses both offer great features for sleepers. The Puffy mattress is a great choice for those who prefer a softer feel, while the Allswell mattress offers more support for sleepers with back pain.

Both models are constructed from quality materials and provide good temperature regulation. Motion isolation is also excellent on both models. The biggest difference between the two is their firmness level, so you should choose based on your needs and preferences.

Overall, if you’re looking for a supportive mattress with great temperature regulation and motion isolation, then either one could be a great fit for you. But if you want something softer or firmer than average, then the Puffy or Allswell might just be perfect. Ultimately it’s up to you to decide which mattress works best for your sleeping needs and budget.

If neither of these options suit your needs, there are plenty of other mattresses on the market to consider. Just make sure that whatever option you choose provides good support, comfort and temperature regulation – because those are all key factors in getting a good night’s rest.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Puffy and Allswell mattresses?

Puffy mattresses are constructed using memory foam and polyfoam layers, while Allswell mattresses use a combination of innerspring coils and foam layers. Puffy mattresses are designed for pressure relief and contouring, while Allswell mattresses are built for support and bounce.

Which mattress is better for side sleepers: Puffy or Allswell?

Puffy mattresses are an excellent choice for side sleepers due to their soft, contouring comfort layer. Allswell mattresses also offer pressure relief, but their firmness level may not be suitable for all side sleepers.

Do Puffy and Allswell mattresses have similar prices?

Puffy and Allswell mattresses have different prices. Puffy mattresses are more expensive than Allswell mattresses, but they also offer more advanced materials and features.

Are Puffy mattresses good for people with back pain?

Yes, Puffy mattresses are suitable for people with back pain because they provide excellent pressure relief and contouring support. Their memory foam layer conforms to the sleeper’s body, reducing pressure points and easing back pain.

Do Allswell mattresses sleep hot?

Allswell mattresses are designed to offer a balanced temperature for a comfortable sleep. Their hybrid construction with innerspring coils helps to promote airflow, preventing heat buildup and keeping the sleeper cool.

Can I flip my Puffy or Allswell mattress?

No, both Puffy and Allswell mattresses are designed to be one-sided, meaning they cannot be flipped. However, rotating the mattress every few months can help to extend its lifespan.

What are the warranty periods for Puffy and Allswell mattresses?

Puffy mattresses come with a lifetime warranty, while Allswell mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty.

How do Puffy and Allswell mattresses ship and arrive?

Both Puffy and Allswell mattresses ship for free and arrive compressed in a box. Once the mattress is unboxed, it will take a few hours to expand fully.

Which mattress has better edge support, Puffy or Allswell?

Allswell mattresses have better edge support due to their hybrid construction with innerspring coils. Puffy mattresses use foam layers, which offer less support at the edges.

How long do Puffy and Allswell mattresses last?

Both Puffy and Allswell mattresses are built to last for several years. However, Puffy mattresses are likely to last longer due to their more advanced materials and construction. On average, a Puffy mattress can last up to 10 years, while an Allswell mattress can last up to 8 years.

About Perry Morris

Perry Morris is a freelance writer, columnist, and mattress expert who contributes content for online publications such as New Mattress Time.