Puffy VS Stearns and Foster Mattress Comparison (2023)

Are you shopping for a new mattress but can’t decide between a Puffy or Stearns & Foster? It’s an important decision, so it’s important to do your research. We’ll break down the differences between these two mattresses and help you decide which one is the better option for you.

When it comes to mattresses, comfort and support are key. But different mattress brands offer different levels of support and comfort.

Puffy and Stearns & Foster are two of the most popular mattress brands on the market today, but how do they compare? We’ll explore the differences in design, materials, and features to help you determine if a Puffy or Stearns & Foster is right for you.

We know that finding the perfect mattress isn’t easy, but with a little information about what each brand has to offer, you can make an informed decision that will leave you sleeping soundly every night. So let’s get started!

Puffy Mattress Overview

Puffy Mattress is a popular online mattress brand that offers high-quality mattresses at an affordable price. It’s made with several layers of foam and a breathable cover that provides great support and comfort for sleepers.

The mattress is designed to be comfortable for all sleeping positions and body types, making it a great choice for almost everyone. Puffy also offers a 101 night sleep trial so you can test out the mattress before committing to it.

The main feature of the Puffy Mattress is its unique cooling system, which uses air channels and open cell technology to keep the surface temperature cool. This helps keep you comfortable while you sleep, as well as prevent overheating during the night. Additionally, Puffy has an advanced motion isolation layer that absorbs movement so you won’t be disturbed by your partner’s movements.

The Puffy Mattress comes in both firm and medium feel options, allowing you to find the perfect balance between support and comfort. It also has a 10-year warranty, so you can rest assured that your mattress will last for many years to come. All in all, Puffy is an excellent choice for anyone looking for an affordable but high-quality mattress.

Read our current Puffy mattress review.

Stearns and Foster Mattress Overview

Stearns and Foster mattresses are known for their luxury and craftsmanship.

They are made with high-quality materials, such as advanced memory foam and cooling gel, which provide exceptional comfort and support. The mattress is also designed to last a long time; it has a ten-year warranty. In addition, the mattress is adjustable to fit any body type or sleep preference.

The cost of a Stearns and Foster mattress can be higher than other brands due to its superior quality. However, customers can find great deals on the mattresses when they take advantage of sales or promotions. Customers may also be able to get discounts if they buy multiple products at once.

Overall, Stearns and Foster mattresses provide superior comfort and durability for those who want a luxurious sleeping experience. With the right research and purchase plan, customers can get an incredible deal on one of these mattresses that will last them years.

puffy vs stearns and foster mattress comparison
Puffy mattress vs Stearns and Foster mattress comparison. Which mattress is better?

Construction & Materials

Moving on from the overview of Stearns and Foster mattresses, let’s compare their construction and materials with that of a Puffy mattress. Both brands offer superior quality mattresses, however there are several differences in their construction.

Puffy mattresses are made with a combination of four layers: a cooling foam layer, memory foam layer, support foam layer and an ultra-dense foam base. This combination provides ample support while also responding to temperature changes to keep you comfortable all night long. Additionally, Puffy mattresses use CertiPur-US certified foams which are designed to reduce motion transfer and maximize comfort.

Stearns and Foster mattresses feature five layers of luxurious materials including high quality memory foam and supportive pocketed coils. They also use patented IntelliCoil® HD technology which is designed to provide individualized comfort by conforming to your body’s shape and weight distribution. All Stearns and Foster mattresses come with a Comfort Balance Layer™ which uses Gel Visco Elastic Memory Foam for added pressure relief.

So when it comes to construction, both Puffy and Stearns & Foster offer quality products that provide superior comfort at an affordable price point. With their unique materials, each brand provides its own benefits for your sleeping needs.

Comfort & Support

When it comes to comfort and support, both the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses offer different levels of support.

The Puffy mattress offers a medium-firm feel that is perfect for side sleepers who need some extra cushioning in order to remain comfortable throughout the night. On the other hand, the Stearns & Foster mattress offers a medium-plush feel that is ideal for back and stomach sleepers who need more support from their mattress.

In terms of motion transfer, both mattresses do an excellent job of minimizing motion transfer across the surface of the bed. The Puffy mattress is especially good at isolating motion, as it features individually wrapped coils and memory foam layers that help to absorb movement. Meanwhile, the Stearns & Foster mattress utilizes advanced pocketed coil technology to reduce motion transfer while still providing superior comfort and support.

Overall, both the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses provide excellent levels of comfort and support. Whether you’re a side sleeper or a back sleeper, either one of these mattresses will provide you with a restful night’s sleep. With high-quality materials and advanced construction techniques, these two mattresses offer great value for money when it comes to comfort and support.

Firmness & Feel

When it comes to firmness and feel, there is a clear distinction between the Puffy mattress and the Stearns & Foster mattress.

The Puffy mattress is designed to be plush and comfortable with its top layer of supportive foam and core layer of memory foam. This combination creates a medium-firm feel that supports the body while providing cushioning and comfort.

In comparison, the Stearns & Foster mattress has an innerspring core with layers of latex and memory foam on top. This configuration results in a firmer feel that provides excellent support but lacks much cushioning or contouring.

The firmness level of the Puffy mattress can also be adjusted by swapping out different layers of foam. This gives sleepers more control over their comfort level, making it easier to find their ideal sleep surface. On the other hand, the Stearns & Foster mattress does not offer this same level of adjustability, meaning you are stuck with what you get from the factory.

Overall, it is clear that each mattress offers something different when it comes to firmness and feel. The Puffy mattress is best for those looking for a plush feel with adjustable support levels, while the Stearns & Foster mattress is better for those who prefer a firmer surface without much cushioning or contouring.

Pressure Relief

Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses both offer great pressure relief. Puffy’s mattress is made with layers of foam that contour to your body, relieving pressure from your shoulders, back, and hips.

It also has a cooling layer that helps keep you cool while you sleep. Stearns & Foster’s mattress is designed with layers of supportive coils and foam that provide superior support for your entire body. The mattress also uses advanced materials like Titanium Memory Foam to help absorb motion from the sleeper.

Both mattresses offer different levels of comfort depending on the firmness level chosen. Puffy offers three firmness options, Soft, Medium-Firm, and Firm. Stearns & Foster provides five different comfort levels ranging from Plush Soft to Extra Firm. Both mattresses provide excellent support for side sleepers who need extra cushioning around the shoulders and hips.

When evaluating the pressure relief provided by these two mattress brands, it’s important to consider how they will feel for individuals with varying body types and sleeping styles. Puffy has a slight edge in this category due to its softer feel and better cooling properties, while Stearns & Foster offers more support for heavier individuals or those who prefer a firmer mattress option.

Ultimately, both brands offer quality pressure relief that should work well for most sleepers regardless of their preferences or body type.

Temperature Regulation

When it comes to temperature regulation, puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses offer different advantages.

Puffy mattresses are great for those who tend to sleep hot as they are made with cooling material like gel-infused foam that helps regulate body temperature. The mattress also has a breathable cover that dissipates heat away from your body.

On the other hand, Stearns & Foster mattresses are designed with high-quality coils and individually pocketed springs that provide superior support and allow air to circulate freely through the mattress, so you don’t get too hot while you sleep.

In addition, both types of mattresses come with layers of foam that help provide cushioning and support for your body while you sleep. Puffy mattresses feature their proprietary Cooling Cloud foam layer which is designed to keep your body cool and comfortable all night long. Stearns & Foster mattresses have a layer of advanced TEMPUR-ES comfort foam which gently contours to your body shape while providing superior pressure relief.

Overall, both types of mattresses offer good temperature regulation but each one may be better suited for different kinds of sleepers depending on their individual needs. For example, if you tend to sleep hot then a puffy mattress may be the best option since it’s specifically designed to keep you cool throughout the night. But if you’re looking for more support while still staying cool then a Stearns & Foster mattress could be the way to go.

puffy mattress
Puffy mattress

Edge Support

Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses both offer excellent support along their edges. Puffy’s mattress features a combination of foam layers that are designed to provide superior comfort and support. The top layer is made from high-density polyfoam and memory foam, while the second layer contains a base layer of dense polyfoam for added firmness. This combination helps to keep the mattress stable when sleeping near the edge.

Meanwhile, Stearns & Foster’s mattress has a unique comfort system with two layers of gel memory foam and one layer of high-density polyfoam. This combination allows for superior edge support while still providing a comfortable night’s sleep. The foam layers are also reinforced along the edges so you can get the most out of your sleeping experience without worrying about rolling off the side.

Overall, both Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses offer excellent edge support, which makes them an ideal choice for those who want to enjoy a good night’s sleep without worrying about uncomfortable sinkage or sagging on the sides.

Motion Isolation

The Puffy mattress and the Stearns & Foster mattress have different levels of motion isolation. The Puffy mattress has a lot of motion isolation, thanks to its memory foam layer that absorbs movement and prevents it from transferring across the bed. On the other hand, the Stearns & Foster mattress has less motion isolation due to its innerspring core and pocketed coils, which allow for movement to travel across the bed.

When it comes to sleeping partners, the Puffy mattress is a great option for couples because of its excellent motion isolation capabilities. It prevents one partner from disturbing the other, allowing for an undisturbed night’s sleep. Conversely, due to its innerspring construction, couples may find that they experience more disturbances from their partner on the Stearns & Foster mattress.

Overall, if you’re looking for a mattress with superior motion isolation capabilities, look no further than the Puffy mattress. Its memory foam layer will provide you with a peaceful night’s sleep free of any disruptions caused by your partner’s movements.

Price Comparison

When it comes to the comparison between Puffy and Stearns and Foster mattresses, the price tag can be a deciding factor. While both brands offer luxurious comfort, they vary in terms of cost. The Puffy mattress is more affordable than the Stearns and Foster mattress, making it an attractive option for shoppers on a budget.

The Puffy mattress ranges from $795 to $1,595 depending on size. This price includes free shipping, a 100-night sleep trial, and a lifetime warranty. On the other hand, the Stearns and Foster mattress ranges from $799 to over $4,000 for their top-of-the-line models. They also offer free shipping, but their sleep trial is only 30 nights long and their warranty only covers 10 years.

In comparison to other luxury mattress brands, both Puffy and Stearns and Foster are reasonably priced. However, when comparing these two brands side by side, Puffy offers more value for your money with its longer sleep trial period and lifetime warranty coverage. This makes it the preferred choice among budget conscious shoppers looking for high quality sleep solutions at an affordable price.

Warranty & Return Policy

When it comes to warranty and return policies, Puffy and Stearns & Foster offer different options.

Puffy provides a lifetime warranty on their mattresses that covers any defect in workmanship or materials. It also covers indentations of 1 inch or greater. Customers can return their mattress within 101 nights of purchase for a full refund, minus shipping costs.

Stearns & Foster’s warranty is slightly different. Theirs covers any defects in the material or craftsmanship for up to 10 years after purchase. If an indentation occurs during this time, they will repair or replace the mattress at no additional cost to the customer. Stearns & Foster also has a 120-night trial period for customers to test out their mattress before deciding whether to keep it or not.

Overall, both companies offer generous warranties and return policies that should give customers peace of mind when making their purchase decision.

Shipping & Delivery

When shopping for a new mattress, delivery and shipping options are important considerations. Both Puffy and Stearns & Foster provide free White Glove delivery services on all of their mattresses. This means that not only will your mattress be delivered directly to your doorstep, but it will also be set up in the room of your choice.

In addition, both companies offer their own satisfaction guarantees. Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial with a full refund if you are not happy with your purchase. Stearns & Foster has a 120-night sleep trial, as well as an exclusive Comfort Exchange program which allows customers to exchange their mattress within the first 120 days if they are unhappy with it.

Overall, both Puffy and Stearns & Foster offer great delivery and shipping options as well as generous satisfaction guarantees that make it easy to buy a new mattress without worrying about returns or exchanges.

Customer Reviews

When it comes to customer reviews of puffy vs. Stearns and Foster Mattresses, there are mixed opinions.

Those who have tried out the Puffy mattress tend to be pleased with their purchase, commenting on its comfort and support, as well as its reasonable price point.

They also like that the mattress is made in America and is CertiPUR-US certified for safety. On the other hand, customers who bought the Stearns and Foster Mattress often comment on its high quality construction and luxurious feel. The only downside they mention is that it can be quite expensive compared to other mattresses on the market.

Overall, both brands offer a good night’s sleep but people have different preferences when it comes to pricing and comfort levels. Ultimately, choosing a mattress should come down to personal preference after considering all factors such as cost, firmness level and features offered.

For those looking for a more affordable option with good quality construction, the Puffy mattress may be a better choice while those willing to spend more money for a higher end product should consider Stearns & Foster.

With so many different options available in today’s market, shoppers should do their research before making an informed decision about which mattress best suits their needs.

Pros & Cons

The Puffy mattress offers a variety of advantages. Firstly, it is very affordable and can be purchased for less than $1,000. It is also highly customizable, allowing customers to select the firmness level that best suits their needs.

Additionally, it has outstanding temperature regulation capabilities; this is particularly beneficial to those who sleep hot or experience discomfort due to sweating at night.

On the other hand, the Stearns and Foster mattress can be more expensive than the Puffy, depending on the model chosen. Furthermore, its customization options are limited in comparison to the Puffy mattress. In terms of temperature regulation, Stearns and Foster mattresses offer only average performance in this area.

When it comes to durability and longevity, both mattresses are very reliable with similar lifespans. However, Stearns and Foster mattresses typically require more frequent flipping than Puffy mattresses do in order to maintain optimal comfort levels over time.

Finally, both brands offer generous warranties that cover any potential defects in materials or workmanship for up to ten years from purchase date. Therefore, customers should feel confident purchasing either brand without worrying about having to replace the mattress soon after purchase due to manufacturing issues.

Puffy vs Stearns and Foster Final Verdict

To sum up, both the Puffy and Stearns & Foster mattresses have their advantages.

The Puffy mattress is a great option for those looking for a comfortable and supportive bed that is also affordable. It has a luxurious feel, with its unique foam layers providing superior support and pressure relief. On the other hand, the Stearns & Foster mattress provides superior comfort and support with its individually wrapped coils and latex foam layers.

When it comes to comparing these two mattresses, there are several factors to consider. First, Puffy mattresses are more affordable than Stearns & Foster mattresses; however, they may not provide as much support or comfort as the latter.

Second, Stearns & Foster mattresses come with an extended warranty period compared to the Puffy mattress. Finally, when it comes to overall customer satisfaction, the two brands are quite similar; however, customers who prefer luxury beds may find that the Stearns & Foster mattress offers better quality.

All in all, both mattresses offer unique benefits and features that make them great options for different types of sleepers. Ultimately, it’s important to choose a mattress that is most suitable for your individual needs and budget.

Is Puffy Mattress Better Than Stearns and Foster Mattress?

It’s clear that both the Puffy and Stearns and Foster mattresses offer great features. The Puffy is a medium-firm mattress with top-notch construction and materials that provide comfort and support for sleepers of all sizes.

Meanwhile, the Stearns and Foster mattress offers a slightly firmer feel that may be more comfortable for side sleepers or heavier individuals. Both companies also provide excellent shipping and delivery services, as well as positive customer reviews.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference when it comes to deciding which mattress is right for you. If you’re looking for a softer mattress with great pressure relief, the Puffy might be perfect for you. But if you prefer a firmer feel with exceptional contouring, then the Stearns and Foster could be the way to go.

No matter which one you choose, we’re sure that either will make a great addition to your bedroom! So take your time to consider all of these factors when selecting your new bed – it’s worth taking the time to get it right so you can enjoy many restful nights of sleep.

For more information:

Visit Puffy’s website https://puffy.com

Visit Stearns and Foster’s website https://www.stearnsandfoster.com

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Puffy and Stearns and Foster mattresses?

Puffy mattresses are known for their all-foam construction, while Stearns and Foster mattresses are made with a combination of foam and innerspring coils. Puffy mattresses are also designed to provide pressure relief and contour to the body, while Stearns and Foster mattresses are designed for both support and comfort.

Which brand offers better motion isolation?

Both Puffy and Stearns and Foster mattresses offer good motion isolation. However, Puffy mattresses are typically better at isolating motion due to their all-foam construction, which absorbs more movement than Stearns and Foster’s innerspring coils.

Which brand is better for people with back pain?

Both brands can be suitable for people with back pain, but Puffy mattresses are typically better at providing pressure relief and conforming to the body’s curves, which can help alleviate back pain. Stearns and Foster mattresses are also designed for support and comfort, but their innerspring coils may not offer as much pressure relief as all-foam mattresses.

Do Puffy mattresses sleep hot?

Puffy mattresses are designed to provide a cool and comfortable sleeping surface. Their top layer of gel-infused foam helps regulate temperature and prevent heat retention, making them a good choice for people who tend to sleep hot.

Are Stearns and Foster mattresses durable?

Stearns and Foster mattresses are known for their durability and longevity. They are made with high-quality materials and are designed to withstand years of use without losing their shape or support.

Do Puffy mattresses have a strong odor?

Puffy mattresses may have a slight odor when first unpacked, but this is normal and should dissipate within a few hours. Puffy uses CertiPUR-US certified foams that are low in VOCs and don’t emit harmful chemicals.

Which brand offers a better warranty?

Both Puffy and Stearns and Foster offer good warranties on their mattresses. Puffy offers a lifetime warranty, while Stearns and Foster offers a 10-year warranty. However, Puffy’s warranty covers more issues, including sagging and body impressions, than Stearns and Foster’s warranty.

Are Puffy mattresses suitable for all sleeping positions?

Puffy mattresses are designed to provide pressure relief and contour to the body, making them suitable for all sleeping positions. However, side sleepers may find them particularly comfortable, as they can help alleviate pressure points in the hips and shoulders.

Which brand offers better edge support?

Stearns and Foster mattresses typically offer better edge support than Puffy mattresses due to their innerspring coils, which provide more support around the perimeter of the mattress.

How do Puffy and Stearns and Foster mattresses compare in terms of price?

Puffy mattresses are generally more affordable than Stearns and Foster mattresses. However, both brands offer a range of models at different price points, so it’s important to compare the features and benefits of each model before making a purchase.

About Perry Morris

Perry Morris is a freelance writer, columnist, and mattress expert who contributes content for online publications such as New Mattress Time.