Puffy VS Amerisleep Mattress Comparison (2023)

Have you been considering a new mattress, but can’t decide which one to get? Puffy and Amerisleep are two of the most popular mattress brands today, and if you’re trying to determine which one is best for your needs, you’ve come to the right place. We’ll provide a comprehensive comparison of the Puffy vs Amerisleep mattresses so that you can make an informed decision.

Puffy has established itself as one of the premier mattress companies in recent years. Their flagship product, The Puffy Royal Mattress, is renowned for its comfort, support, and durability. It’s also backed by a lifetime warranty, so you know it’s made to last. On the other hand, Amerisleep has been offering top-notch mattresses since 2006. Their products are designed with advanced cooling technology to keep sleepers cool throughout the night. They also offer generous trial periods and warranties on their mattresses.

We’ll take a close look at both brands and compare them side-by-side in terms of comfort, value for money, construction quality and more. We’ll also provide our verdict on which one will be better suited for different types of sleepers. So stick around and find out if Puffy or Amerisleep is the perfect mattress for you.

Puffy Mattresses

Puffy mattresses are a collection of memory foam mattresses created by Puffy Lux, LLC. The Puffy mattress lineup includes the Puffy Mattress, the Puffy Lux, and the Puffy Royal. All three mattresses feature memory foam that’s designed to provide support for all sleeping styles and body types. The mattress is also breathable and temperature-regulating, helping to keep sleepers cool throughout the night.

The Puffy Mattress is the original in the series and features two layers of foam – a top layer of Cooling Cloud Foam as well as a base layer of Firm Core Support Foam. This combination helps to provide a supportive sleep surface that relieves pressure points while giving enough bounce to move around easily. The Puffy Lux is an upgraded version with five layers, including the same top and bottom layers as the original plus three additional layers for extra cushioning, comfort, and contouring. Finally, the Puffy Royal combines seven layers of foam for maximum support and comfort.

All three mattresses come with a 101-night trial period so customers can make sure they’re satisfied with their purchase before committing to it completely. In addition, each mattress comes with a lifetime warranty so you can rest assured that your investment will be protected in case something goes wrong.

Read our review of Puffy mattress.

Amerisleep Mattresses

Amerisleep mattresses are designed to provide a comfortable and supportive sleep experience. They are constructed with memory foam mattress top layers, comfort layers, and foam layers. The memory foam mattress top layer helps to reduce pressure points, while the comfort layers provide cushioning and support for the body. The foam layers also help to evenly distribute body weight for maximum support and comfort.

The Amerisleep mattress range includes a variety of different types of mattresses including innerspring, memory foam, hybrid, and latex mattresses. All of these types of mattresses offer different levels of comfort and support depending on an individual’s needs. Innerspring mattresses provide a firm feel that is best suited for those who prefer a firmer surface to sleep on.

Memory foam mattresses contour to the body for more comfort. Hybrid mattresses combine both innerspring coils and memory foam for greater support and motion isolation. Latex mattresses have a bouncy feel that is great for people who like responsive beds.

No matter which type of Amerisleep mattress you choose, you can be sure that it will provide superior comfort and support throughout your sleep cycle. With its wide selection of mattress types, Amerisleep has something for everyone no matter what their sleeping preferences are.

Construction & Materials

The Puffy mattress is constructed with a 3-layer memory foam bed. It features a 2-inch comfort layer made from cooling Cloud Comfort foam and a 7-inch base layer of high-density core support foam. Additionally, the mattress has a unique top layer of Cooling Cloud Foam that uses gel beads to absorb body heat and keep your bed cool during sleep.

In comparison, the Amerisleep mattress is also made with three layers. It features two comfort layers – one made from AirFoam and the other from Bio-Core foam – as well as an 8-inch support base of BioCore foam. The AirFoam layer offers extra cushioning while the BioCore adds edge support for better stability on the sides. Both mattresses feature memory foam that contours to your body for pressure relief but, due to its unique design, the Puffy mattress may be slightly cooler than the Amerisleep mattress.

Overall, both mattresses offer comfort and pressure relief thanks to their memory foam construction. However, if you are looking for something that sleeps cooler or has more edge support, then you may want to consider either the Puffy or Amerisleep mattress depending on your needs.

Firmness, Support & Comfort

Moving on from construction and materials, both the Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses offer support and comfort appropriate for most kinds of sleepers. When it comes to back pain relief, both brands provide an even balance between firmness level and pressure point relief.

The Puffy mattress is designed to offer a medium-firm feel that can accommodate most sleeping positions. It also has additional layers of cooling foam for enhanced comfort throughout the night. The Amerisleep mattress is slightly firmer than the Puffy, but still offers good pressure relief and cushioning. It also features a unique memory foam layer that helps provide support for your lumbar region while also helping to reduce motion transfer.

Overall, both models can be considered good options when it comes to providing a comfortable sleeping surface with enough support for back pain relief. They are both well-constructed with quality materials that can hold up over time. Ultimately, the choice between these two mattress models should be based on personal preference and individual needs.

Temperature Regulation

When it comes to temperature regulation, Puffy and Amerisleep have different approaches. Puffy has a special cooling system designed to keep you cool while sleeping. Its top layer is composed of cooling foam that absorbs heat away from your body and keeps it cool all night long. Its quilted cover also adds an extra layer for additional breathability. On the other hand, Amerisleep uses a combination of open-cell memory foam and cooling gel technology to help regulate temperatures for side sleepers who need pressure relief. It also features a medium firmness level that helps provide support without overheating.

When it comes to price range, Puffy is more affordable than Amerisleep’s Tempur Pedic mattress models. However, both offer good value for money, so it ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget when making the decision.

Overall, both mattresses are great options when it comes to temperature regulation, but each one offers unique benefits depending on individual needs. Ultimately, deciding which one is right for you depends on your specific requirements and preferences in terms of comfort and budget.

Edge Support & Motion Isolation

Moving on to edge support and motion isolation, both mattresses offer exceptional support. Puffy has a unique foam construction that ensures optimal support for those who sleep on their stomachs or suffer from hip pain.

It also includes an advanced cooling system which helps with temperature regulation throughout the night. Amerisleep, on the other hand, offers a foam core that provides superior motion isolation and edge support. This mattress is also covered by a lifetime warranty so you can rest assured that your purchase will last for years to come.

When it comes to motion isolation, both mattresses provide excellent results. Puffy’s foam construction helps reduce movement transfer from one side of the bed to the other, while Amerisleep’s foam core prevents any disturbances caused by a partner’s movements during sleep. Both mattresses also perform well when it comes to providing edge support and helping alleviate hip pain for stomach sleepers.

Regardless of your sleeping position or preference, either mattress is sure to provide comfort and support throughout the night. Puffy offers great temperature regulation features and its unique foam construction offers excellent motion isolation and edge support, while Amerisleep has a foam core that helps minimize disturbance from partner movements and includes a lifetime warranty for added peace of mind. Ultimately, it all boils down to personal preference as both mattresses offer exceptional performance when it comes to motion isolation and edge support.

Price Comparison

When it comes to price, Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses differ significantly. The Puffy mattress is more affordable, with prices starting from $795 for a Twin size. Amerisleep beds range from $959 to $1,899, depending on the size. For larger sizes like King or California King, the difference in price between the two brands is even greater. Additionally, Puffy offers discounts to veterans and first responders.

Both companies offer financing options with 0% APR for up to 12 months on select products. However, Puffy also provides an additional option of 0% financing over 24 months. So if you’re looking to spread out payments over a longer period of time, Puffy may be the better choice.

In terms of overall value for money, both mattresses have their own advantages and disadvantages. Puffy offers more competitive pricing and flexible financing options that can make it easier to purchase a mattress within your budget. On the other hand, Amerisleep’s beds are made with higher quality materials that may last longer than those of Puffy’s mattresses. Ultimately, it comes down to your individual needs and preferences when deciding which mattress is right for you.

puffy vs amerisleep mattress comparison. We compare price, firmness, construction, features, and warranty
Puffy mattress vs Amerisleep mattress comparison. Which mattress is better?

Warranty & Sleep Trial Comparison

When it comes to warranties and sleep trials, Puffy and Amerisleep have slightly different approaches. Puffy offers a lifetime warranty on their mattresses, meaning that they will replace any defective parts at no extra cost. They also offer a 101-night sleep trial for customers. On the other hand, Amerisleep provides a 20-year limited warranty with their mattresses and gives customers 100 days to decide if the mattress is right for them.

The Puffy warranty covers any manufacturing defects in workmanship or materials, as well as sagging of more than 1 inch that isn’t caused by improper support from the foundation or bed frame. The Amerisleep warranty also covers manufacturing defects, but only up to two inches of sagging due to normal wear and tear. In addition, Amerisleep’s warranty covers indentations of more than one inch that are not caused by improper support.

Both companies stand behind their products by offering long-term warranties and generous sleep trials that allow customers to make sure they’re happy with their purchase before committing to it fully. When comparing these two options, it’s clear that both brands provide quality service and protection for their customers.

Shipping & Delivery Comparison

When it comes to shipping and delivery, Puffy offers free delivery for all orders within the United States. Customers will receive their mattress within three to five business days via FedEx or UPS. Puffy also offers white glove delivery services, which includes setup of the mattress in the bedroom and hauling away of any old mattresses.

On the other hand, Amerisleep also offers free shipping but only in certain states. Delivery is done through a local partner and customers should expect their mattress within five to seven business days. However, there are no options for white glove services available with Amerisleep.

Overall, if you’re looking for fast delivery and a convenient set up of your mattress, then Puffy may be the better choice due to its free shipping throughout the US and its white glove service option.

Customer Reviews

When it comes to customer reviews, both Puffy and Amerisleep have overwhelmingly positive feedback. On the Puffy website, customers praise its top-notch comfort and quality materials. They also love that it’s made in the USA and comes with a lifetime warranty. Amerisleep users are impressed with its pressure relief, breathability, and motion isolation features. The company has an excellent return policy and customers often comment on how helpful their customer service representatives are.

Overall, both mattress brands have high ratings from customers who appreciate the quality of their products and service. Puffy is praised for its luxurious feel and high-grade materials while Amerisleep is acclaimed for its supportiveness and breathability. Both mattresses offer great value for money considering their competitive prices.

Both Puffy and Amerisleep offer great options when it comes to mattresses, but ultimately it’s up to you as a consumer to decide which one best suits your needs. It’s important to research each brand thoroughly before making a purchase so you can make an informed decision.

Pros & Cons Of Puffy Mattresses

The Puffy mattress has many pros that make it a great choice for those looking for a comfortable, supportive sleep. For starters, the mattress is constructed with a top layer of cooling, pressure-relieving foam and a base layer of supportive foam. This combination allows the mattress to conform to your body while providing excellent support and keeping you cool throughout the night. Additionally, the mattress is also CertiPUR-US certified, meaning that all materials used are safe and non-toxic.

Another pro of the Puffy mattress is its affordability. Compared to some other mattresses on the market, it is much more affordable and can be an excellent option for those who want a quality mattress without breaking the bank. The company also offers free shipping within the US and a 101-night sleep trial so customers can test out their new bed before committing to it.

Finally, Puffy mattresses come with a lifetime warranty which provides peace of mind should any issues arise during ownership. This warranty covers any manufacturing defects or premature sagging that may occur over time. If any problems do occur during ownership, Puffy will replace or repair your mattress at no additional cost to you.

Pros & Cons Of Amerisleep Mattresses

Amerisleep mattresses have several pros that make them a great choice for those looking to purchase a mattress. For starters, Amerisleep offers a wide variety of mattress sizes and models, so customers can easily find one that fits their needs.

Amerisleep also offers a 20-year warranty on their products, giving buyers peace of mind that the mattress will remain in good condition for many years. Additionally, Amerisleep mattresses are made with high quality foam that is designed to provide maximum comfort and support.

The cons of Amerisleep mattresses include the fact that they tend to be more expensive than other brands on the market. Additionally, some consumers may find them too firm or too soft depending on their preferences. Finally, some customers may not like the fact that most Amerisleep mattresses require a box spring or platform bed in order to achieve the desired level of comfort.

Overall, Amerisleep mattresses are an excellent choice for those looking for a comfortable and supportive mattress with long-term durability. Customers should take into consideration both the pros and cons before making their final decision to ensure they get the best mattress for their needs.

Alternatives To Consider

Moving on from Amerisleep mattresses, let’s explore a few alternatives that may better suit your needs. Puffy is a popular choice among shoppers looking for comfort and value. It offers several innovative features, such as their patented Cooling Cloud foam to keep you cool and comfortable all night long. Additionally, the mattress is made with CertiPUR-US certified foam so you know it’s safe and non-toxic.

Another option is the Nectar memory foam mattress. It features a layer of quilted gel memory foam that contours to your body for superior support and comfort every night. It also has a breathable cover with cooling fibers that help regulate temperature throughout the night. Nectar offers an industry-leading 365-night sleep trial so you can test out the mattress for yourself before committing.

No matter what mattress you choose, make sure it meets your needs and provides comfort and support throughout the night. With so many models available, you’re sure to find one that fits your budget and lifestyle.

Final Verdict

When it comes to deciding between the Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses, both offer excellent comfort, support and quality. In terms of firmness, they are both medium-firm, so neither mattress is too soft or too firm. However, Amerisleep has the edge when it comes to pressure relief and motion isolation. The Amerisleep mattress also offers a longer warranty period than Puffy’s 10-year limited warranty. Additionally, the price difference between the two is not significant enough to be a decisive factor in making your decision.

In terms of overall value for money, Puffy is slightly better as it provides more features at a lower cost than Amerisleep. However, if you’re looking for a mattress that offers more comprehensive motion isolation and pressure relief benefits then Amerisleep might be better suited for you. Ultimately, the choice boils down to personal preference – both mattresses offer great comfort and support at an affordable price point.

Ultimately, either mattress will provide comfort and support that can help you get a good night’s sleep every night. It’s important to consider your own preferences and needs before making your decision on which mattress is right for you.

Which Mattress is For You?

When comparing the Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses, both offer a great night’s sleep. Both provide comfort and support while sleeping. The Puffy mattress has a higher density foam that is more durable than the Amerisleep mattress. However, the Amerisleep mattress has a better warranty and is slightly less expensive.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference when deciding which mattress to choose. If you are looking for an affordable option with excellent customer service, then the Puffy mattress may be your best bet. On the other hand, if price is not an issue and you want a longer lasting product with a better warranty, then the Amerisleep mattress might be for you.

No matter what you decide, both mattresses have been designed to help ensure that you get a good night’s sleep each and every night. With either of these options, you can rest assured knowing that you will get quality comfort and support for your body throughout the night.

Is Puffy Mattress Better Than Amerisleep Mattress

It’s clear that both the Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses offer a great night’s sleep. Both are constructed with quality materials and provide excellent support and comfort. The temperature regulation of both mattresses is also noteworthy. However, depending on your preferences, one mattress may be better suited to you than the other.

If you’re looking for a softer mattress with good temperature regulation, then Puffy might be the right choice for you. It’s also significantly more affordable than Amerisleep while still offering comparable features. On the other hand, if you prefer a medium-firm feel and need extra pressure relief, then Amerisleep might be more suitable for you.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference when deciding between the two mattresses. Both are excellent options that offer great value for money in terms of comfort and durability. So take some time to consider which mattress best suits your needs before making a final decision. You won’t regret it.

Facts and Statistics

  1. Puffy mattresses are made with a combination of foam layers, including a patented cooling foam layer, to provide a supportive and comfortable sleep surface.
  2. Amerisleep mattresses are constructed with a combination of foam layers, including a patented Bio-Pur foam layer, to provide a supportive and comfortable sleep surface.
  3. Puffy mattresses are available in three different firmness levels: Soft, Medium, and Firm.
  4. Amerisleep mattresses are available in five different firmness levels: Soft, Medium Soft, Medium, Medium Firm, and Firm.
  5. Puffy mattresses feature a breathable cover made from a blend of polyester and spandex.
  6. Amerisleep mattresses feature a breathable cover made from a blend of polyester and Celliant fibers.
  7. Puffy mattresses are designed to provide pressure relief and support for all sleeping positions.
  1. Puffy mattresses are available in 6 different sizes, while Amerisleep mattresses are available in 5 different sizes.
  2. Puffy mattresses are constructed with 3 layers of foam, while Amerisleep mattresses are constructed with 5 layers of foam.
  3. Puffy mattresses have a 10-year limited warranty, while Amerisleep mattresses have a 20-year limited warranty.
  4. Puffy mattresses have a medium-firm feel, while Amerisleep mattresses have a medium-soft feel.
  5. Puffy mattresses are priced from $795 to $1,395, while Amerisleep mattresses are priced from $699 to $2,399.
  6. Puffy mattresses have a 3.5/5 rating on Amazon, while Amerisleep mattresses have a 4.4/5 rating on Amazon.


  1. https://puffy.com
  2. https://amerisleep.com

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the differences between the Puffy and Amerisleep mattresses?

Puffy and Amerisleep are both memory foam mattresses, but the Puffy is known for its cooling properties and pressure relief, while the Amerisleep is known for its eco-friendly materials and targeted support.

Which mattress is better for side sleepers?

Both mattresses are suitable for side sleepers, but the Amerisleep has zoned support which provides targeted pressure relief for the hips and shoulders, making it the better option for side sleepers.

Which mattress is better for back sleepers?

Both mattresses provide ample support for back sleepers, but the Puffy’s soft foam layers might not provide enough support for heavier individuals. The Amerisleep’s zoned support provides targeted pressure relief for the lower back, making it a better option for back sleepers.

Which mattress is better for stomach sleepers?

Neither mattress is ideal for stomach sleepers as they both lack the necessary support for the hips and abdomen. However, the Amerisleep’s firmer support may be more suitable for stomach sleepers.

Do either of these mattresses sleep hot?

The Puffy is designed with cooling properties that dissipate heat, making it the better option for those who tend to sleep hot. The Amerisleep is made with breathable, plant-based materials that also help regulate temperature.

Which mattress has better motion isolation?

Both mattresses have excellent motion isolation, but the Puffy’s memory foam layers provide slightly better motion isolation compared to the Amerisleep.

Which mattress is better for couples?

Both mattresses are suitable for couples, but the Puffy’s superior motion isolation and cooling properties make it a better option for couples who share a bed.

Do these mattresses come with a sleep trial and warranty?

Both the Puffy and Amerisleep come with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.

How long do these mattresses typically last?

Both mattresses are made with high-quality materials and should last between 7-10 years with proper care and maintenance.

How do the prices compare between these mattresses?

The Puffy is priced slightly lower than the Amerisleep, but both mattresses are competitively priced compared to other high-end memory foam mattresses on the market.

About Perry Morris

Perry Morris is a freelance writer, columnist, and mattress expert who contributes content for online publications such as New Mattress Time.