Puffy VS Saatva Mattress Comparison (2023)

When it comes to finding the perfect mattress, many people are confused about which one to choose.

The two most popular options on the market today are the Puffy Mattress and Saatva Mattress. Both mattresses offer a variety of features, but how do they compare? In this article, we’ll explore the benefits of each in order to help you decide which is best for your needs.

The Puffy mattress is designed with comfort and quality in mind. Its proprietary foam layers make it an ideal choice for those looking for superior support and pressure relief. Additionally, its temperature-regulating cover helps keep you cool at night. On top of these features, Puffy also offers a 10-year warranty and free shipping within the United States.

Saatva’s flagship mattress boasts an array of features that make it a great option for those seeking luxury and comfort. It has individually pocketed coils to provide optimal support as well as organic cotton padding for breathability and comfort. Plus, Saatva backs their product with a 15-year warranty and offers free white glove delivery services to customers in the U.S.

In our comparison of Puffy vs Saatva mattresses, we’ll look at all aspects from firmness level to cost so that you can make an informed decision about which mattress is right for you.

Puffy Mattress Overview

The Puffy mattress is a great choice for those looking for a comfortable and supportive sleep experience.

It’s constructed with high-quality materials like cooling gel memory foam and supportive poly foam, which makes it ideal for all types of sleepers. The mattress also features a unique cooling system that helps keep you cool throughout the night. Plus, the Puffy mattress comes with a lifetime warranty, so you know you’re investing in a quality product.

The Puffy mattress is designed to provide pressure relief and support where it’s needed most. Its layers of high-density foam cradle your body while reducing pressure points, resulting in fewer aches and pains when you wake up in the morning.

In addition, the mattress has an excellent edge support system that prevents sagging or sinking near the edges of the bed. This ensures that every inch of your sleeping surface remains comfortable and supportive.

Overall, the Puffy mattress is an excellent option for those who value comfort and support in their sleep experience. It offers superior pressure relief, edge support, cooling technology, and peace of mind due to its lifetime warranty. With so many features packed into one mattress, it’s no wonder why people love this bed!

See our latest review of Puffy mattresses.

Saatva Mattress Overview

Moving on from the Puffy Mattress overview, let’s take a look at the Saatva mattress. This mattress is a hybrid innerspring model that features two layers of coils and foam comfort layers. It offers superior support for the spine and hips, making it the perfect choice for those looking for a firmer mattress.

The first layer of the Saatva mattress consists of pocketed coils that provide plenty of bounce and contouring support. The second layer is made up of individually wrapped coils that are designed to reduce motion transfer and give extra cushioning. On top of these coil layers are two layers of foam which provide additional comfort and pressure relief.

Overall, the Saatva mattress is an excellent choice for those seeking firm support with some cushioning. It offers great motion isolation and breathability, making it an ideal option for couples who share a bed. With its combination of quality materials and thoughtful design, this mattress is sure to offer years of peaceful sleep.

puffy vs saatva mattress comparison
Puffy mattress vs Saatva mattress comparison. Which mattress is better?

Materials And Construction

Puffy and Saatva mattresses differ in their materials and construction.

Puffy is a 10-inch mattress made up of three layers. The top layer is two inches of cooling CloudFoam, followed by two inches of FirmCore Support Foam, and then six inches of high-density base foam. This combination provides great support while still being soft and comfortable.

Saatva, on the other hand, is an 11.5-inch hybrid mattress with a coil system for optimal comfort and support. It has a euro pillow top that’s quilted with high quality foam; beneath this is a layer of individually wrapped coils for contouring support; followed by a layer of high-density foam for additional cushioning; and finally, the bottom layer consists of heavy duty steel coils to provide extra support.

Both mattresses are designed to offer maximum comfort while also providing necessary back support. They also use CertiPUR certified foams that don’t contain toxins or chemicals, so they’re both safe to sleep on as well as environmentally friendly.

Comfort & Support

Moving on from materials and construction, let’s look at the comfort and support offered by a puffy mattress and a Saatva mattress. Comfort is a subjective experience, so it is hard to compare two mattresses in this area. However, both mattresses have features that are designed to provide comfort to the sleeper.

A Puffy mattress has layers of foam that contour to your body while providing pressure relief. The top layer of the mattress contains gel-infused memory foam, which helps keep you cool while sleeping. Additionally, the mattress has an extra-soft foam layer that helps reduce pain points and adds cushioning for increased comfort.

Saatva mattresses provide support through its individually wrapped coils with varying levels of firmness. This feature helps align your spine and provides pressure relief where needed most. It also has a plush Euro pillow top for added cushioning, as well as a lumbar pad for extra lower back support.

Overall, both puffy and Saatva mattresses offer comfort and support options to help suit individual needs. Both offer features that contour to the body’s shape, provide pressure relief and help keep the user cool during sleep.

Firmness & Feel

The firmness and feel of the two mattresses differ significantly.

The Puffy mattress is slightly softer than the Saatva mattress, with a medium-soft feel that many find comfortable. It is composed of three layers of foam, including memory foam and polyfoam, which gives it a slightly softer overall feel than the Saatva mattress.

The Saatva mattress is considered to be medium-firm and is made up of two layers of coils, surrounded by cushioning foam layers. This design gives it more support than the Puffy mattress while still providing comfort.

The Puffy mattress has an adaptive and contouring feeling due to its memory foam layer. It also helps reduce pressure points, making it a good choice for side sleepers who require extra cushioning to avoid shoulder pain or discomfort.

The Saatva mattress provides excellent lumbar support and has an innerspring system that increases airflow so that sleepers don’t overheat during the night. Both mattresses are great options for those who want an adjustable sleeping surface as they both offer adjustable bases that allow you to customize your sleep position.

When comparing the two mattresses, it’s clear that each one offers something different in terms of comfort and support. Depending on individual preferences and sleeping habits, either could be a good option for those looking for a new mattress. Both provide quality materials, innovative designs, and customizable features to help ensure you get a restful night’s sleep every night.

Temperature Regulation

When it comes to temperature regulation, both the Puffy mattress and Saatva mattress offer excellent cooling capabilities.

The Puffy mattress is constructed with a unique blend of foam layers that help promote air circulation, which helps to keep the sleep surface cool for longer periods of time. Saatva’s luxury firm mattress is designed with an advanced coil system that allows the mattress to breathe better than traditional foams. This increases airflow, helping regulate temperature throughout the night.

The Puffy mattress also features a special Cooling Cloud foam layer that helps dissipate heat from your body, while Saatva’s pillow top cover also helps to keep you cool. Both mattresses are also made with breathable materials that help keep air circulating freely around your body to reduce overheating.

Overall, both mattresses provide excellent temperature regulation capabilities and are great options for those who tend to get hot during the night. With their combination of breathable materials and cooling technologies, both mattresses will keep you comfortable all night long without getting too hot.

Edge Support

Transitioning from temperature regulation, edge support is another important consideration when comparing mattresses. This is an area where the two mattresses differ significantly.

The Puffy mattress has a foam core with no springs or coils, meaning there is no reinforced border around the edges. This provides a softer feel on the edges of the mattress and can be beneficial for those who need to sit up in bed for activities like reading or watching TV. However, it does not provide enough stability for those who sleep near the edge of the bed or need to get out of bed quickly and easily.

The Saatva mattress, on the other hand, features coil-on-coil construction which provides superior edge support compared to many other beds. The individually wrapped coils are arranged around a sturdy perimeter that helps prevent sagging and roll-off. As a result, it feels secure even when you’re lying close to the edge and makes it easy to get off and on without sinking into the mattress too much.

Overall, if you need extra support when sleeping near the edges of your bed then Saatva is likely your best choice. Not only does its design provide more stability but also offers better responsiveness than Puffy’s foam core construction.

puffy mattress
Puffy mattress

Motion Isolation

When it comes to motion isolation, the Puffy mattress and Saatva mattress are both excellent choices.

The Puffy mattress is constructed with several layers of foam that absorb movement, ensuring that you won’t feel your partner tossing or turning in bed. Additionally, its top layer of cloud foam contours to your body for better motion absorption.

On the other hand, the Saatva mattress uses a combination of coils and layers of foam to provide superior motion isolation. Its two-stage coil system minimizes motion transfer and its memory foam comfort layer conforms to your body for enhanced cushioning. So no matter which option you choose, you can rest assured that you won’t be disturbed by any movements during the night.

However, when it comes to edge support, there are some differences between these mattresses. The Puffy mattress has an edge support system consisting of high-density polyfoam along the perimeter that helps prevent sagging and keep you supported while sitting on the edge of the bed. In comparison, the Saatva mattress features a patented spine-support system with reinforced edges that help maintain spinal alignment while providing extra stability at the edges.

Overall, both the Puffy mattress and Saatva mattress provide superior motion isolation so you can get a peaceful night’s sleep without being disturbed by any movements from your partner. But if edge support is important to you then it’s worth considering which design offers more in this area before making your purchase decision.

Price Comparison

Moving on to the next important comparison, price. When it comes to mattresses, price is an important factor for many consumers. The Puffy mattress is available in six sizes and starts at $795, while the Saatva mattress starts at $999. Both mattresses have different features that can affect their prices, such as construction materials or additional features like cooling technology.

The Puffy mattress is a foam-based bed made with cooling gel memory foam and two layers of polyfoam. It also has a lifetime warranty and 101-night sleep trial for its customers.

On the other hand, the Saatva mattress is constructed with coils and layers of memory foam, latex, and support foams. This luxury hybrid mattress also comes with a lifetime warranty and 180-night sleep trial period.

In terms of pricing, both mattresses are competitively priced for their respective levels of quality and comfort. Therefore, it ultimately depends on the customer’s preference when it comes to deciding between these two options. For those looking for an affordable option with good comfort levels, then the Puffy mattress could be ideal; however if premium comfort is desired then the Saatva mattress may be more suitable.

Pressure Relief

When it comes to pressure relief, both mattresses have their advantages.

The Puffy mattress is made with a combination of high-density foam and a layer of cooling gel foam. This gives the mattress a softer feel that contours to the body and relieves pressure points so you can get a good night’s sleep.

On the other hand, the Saatva mattress has a layer of individually encased coils and two layers of memory foam. This provides a firmer feel that still manages to relieve pressure points while providing good support for your body.

The difference between these two mattresses largely depends on personal preference. If you’re looking for something softer, then the Puffy mattress may be more suitable for you. However, if you prefer something firmer, then the Saatva mattress is probably the better option. Ultimately, both mattresses offer great pressure relief and provide an overall comfortable sleeping experience.

To sum up, both mattresses provide excellent pressure relief in different ways depending on individual preferences. Both offer great support and comfort so that you can enjoy a good night’s rest every night.

Warranty & Return Policy

The pressure relief offered by both the Puffy and Saatva mattresses is remarkable. Now, let’s compare their warranty and return policies to further evaluate which mattress might be a better choice for you.

Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial, during which customers can try out the mattress risk-free. If they decide that the mattress isn’t a good fit, they can contact Puffy to arrange for it to be picked up and refunded in full. The mattress also comes with a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects or sagging greater than one inch.

The Saatva mattress has a 180-night sleep trial period, giving customers more time to test it out before making a decision. If they decide that it’s not right for them, they can get their money back as long as the mattress is still in good condition. Saatva also provides an extended 15-year warranty that covers any sagging deeper than one inch as well as any manufacturing defects.

Both brands offer generous return policies and warranties that ensure your satisfaction with your purchase. Ultimately, each customer will have to decide which option works best for them based on their individual preferences and needs.

Delivery And Returns

When it comes to delivery and returns, the two mattresses offer different experiences.

Puffy offers free shipping in the contiguous United States and a 101 night sleep trial. If you decide that the mattress does not work for you within those 101 nights, they’ll provide you with a full refund and arrange for the mattress to be donated.

Saatva also offers free shipping in the United States but their return policy is slightly different – they only offer a 45 night sleep trial, after which you can choose between a full or partial refund depending on how long you kept the mattress.

In addition to this, Puffy offers a lifetime warranty while Saatva offers one of 15 years, with both warranties covering any defects or sagging issues that may arise over time. So when it comes to delivery and returns, there are some differences between the two mattresses – however each one has its own advantages worth considering.

Ultimately, it all comes down to personal preference – if you’re looking for more lenient delivery and return policies then Puffy may be your best bet; if you want more security in terms of warranty coverage then Saatva might be what you’re looking for. Whichever one you choose, make sure to read through their respective policies thoroughly before making your final decision.

Customer Service

Moving on, let’s take a look at the customer service offered by both Puffy and Saatva.

Puffy has an online chat feature which allows customers to get answers to their questions quickly. They also offer a phone line and email support, giving customers multiple ways to get in touch with them. Saatva boasts 24/7 customer service via their toll-free telephone number and provides detailed answers to inquiries on their website. They also have a live chat feature for customers who prefer that method of communication.

In terms of response time, Puffy typically responds to queries within an hour or two. Saatva is known for responding quickly as well but can sometimes take longer than Puffy depending on the nature of the inquiry. Both companies are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and making sure that customers are satisfied with their purchase.

Overall, both companies offer great customer service options for those looking for assistance with their mattress purchase or any other issue related to their product. With the availability of online chats, phone lines, and email support from both companies, customers can rest assured knowing they will get the help they need when they need it.

Pros Vs Cons

Pros of the Puffy Mattress: The Puffy mattress is well known for its softness and pressure relief. It has a top layer of cooling foam that helps to keep you cool while sleeping on it. This mattress also features a lifetime warranty, so you know it’s built to last. Additionally, its affordability makes it an attractive option for many people.

Cons of the Puffy Mattress: One downside of the Puffy mattress is that it may feel too soft for some people who prefer a firmer sleeping surface. This mattress also may not provide enough support for heavier individuals, as the foam layers can sink in too much under their weight.

Pros of Saatva Mattress: The Saatva mattress is great for those looking for a firm sleeping surface with good spinal support. It’s made from durable materials, and comes with an impressive 15-year warranty – one year longer than the Puffy mattress! Additionally, this mattress comes with free white glove delivery and setup service included in the purchase price.

Cons of Saatva Mattress: One downside of this mattress is its price – it’s more expensive than other mattresses on the market, including the Puffy mattress. Additionally, some customers have reported that they found this bed to be too firm or uncomfortable due to its firmness level.

Puffy vs Saatva Final Verdict

When it comes to choosing between a Puffy mattress and a Saatva mattress, it’s important to consider your own individual needs. The Puffy mattress offers comfort and support for those with back pain, while the Saatva mattress is ideal for those seeking luxury at an affordable price. Ultimately, the decision should come down to personal preference.

The Puffy mattress is known for its unique CloudComfort technology which helps relieve pressure points and provides superior cushioning and support. It also has a Lifetime Warranty which ensures that you’ll get years of use out of the mattress.

On the other hand, the Saatva mattress combines quality craftsmanship with premium materials for a luxurious sleep experience. It also provides excellent edge support so you can rest assured that you won’t sink into the side of the bed.

Both mattresses are great options, but depending on what you’re looking for, one may be more suitable than the other. If you’re looking for superior comfort and support, then the Puffy mattress is an ideal choice. However, if you’re after exceptional quality at an affordable price then the Saatva mattress might be better suited to your needs. Whichever option you choose, make sure it meets your specific requirements to guarantee a good night’s sleep.

Is Puffy Mattress Better Than Saatva Mattress?

The Puffy mattress and Saatva mattress are both great options for those in search of a new mattress.

The Puffy is a great choice if you’re looking for a responsive foam mattress that provides great pressure relief and comfort. It also comes with an impressive lifetime warranty. On the other hand, the Saatva has two different firmness levels to choose from and is constructed with high-quality coils and layers of foam, making it supportive and durable. It also comes with a 15-year warranty.

Overall, if I had to pick one, I would go with the Puffy mattress because of its superior comfort level and its lengthy warranty. Its combination of foam layers offers superior contouring support that helps relieve pressure points, which can be very helpful for side sleepers like myself. Plus, its lifetime warranty gives me peace of mind knowing I won’t have to replace my mattress anytime soon.

Ultimately, both mattresses offer excellent value for their respective prices and should provide years of comfortable sleep. So no matter which one you decide on, you can rest assured that you’ll be getting top quality products that will last you many years to come.

  1. Puffy mattresses are made with three layers of foam, including a top layer of cooling CloudFoam and a bottom layer of support foam.
  2. Saatva mattresses are made with two layers of coils and two layers of foam, including a top layer of contouring memory foam and a bottom layer of support foam.
  3. Puffy mattresses are designed to provide pressure relief and support for all sleeping positions.
  4. Saatva mattresses are designed to provide support for back and stomach sleepers, as well as some side sleepers.
  5. Puffy mattresses are available in two firmness levels: medium-firm and firm.
  6. Saatva mattresses are available in three firmness levels: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm.
  7. Puffy mattresses are made with CertiPUR-US certified foam, which is free of ozone depleters, heavy metals, and other harmful materials.
  1. Puffy mattresses are available in 6 different sizes (Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King) while Saatva mattresses are available in 5 different sizes (Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Split King).
  2. Puffy mattresses are 10 inches thick while Saatva mattresses are available in 11.5, 14.5, and 16 inch thicknesses.
  3. Puffy mattresses are constructed with three layers of foam while Saatva mattresses are constructed with two layers of foam and a coil system.
  4. Puffy mattresses have a medium-firm feel while Saatva mattresses are available in three different firmness levels (plush soft, luxury firm, and firm).

For more information:

Visit Puffy’s website https://puffy.com

Visit Saatva’s website https://www.saatva.com

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between Puffy and Saatva mattresses?

Puffy is an all-foam mattress designed to provide exceptional comfort and pressure relief, while Saatva is a hybrid mattress made with a combination of foam and innerspring coils. Saatva is also available in three firmness levels, while Puffy only offers one firmness option.

Which mattress is better for side sleepers, Puffy or Saatva?

Puffy is considered the better option for side sleepers because of its excellent pressure relief capabilities. Its soft foam layers conform to the body’s curves, providing targeted support and comfort. Saatva, on the other hand, may be too firm for some side sleepers, especially those who prefer a softer mattress.

Which mattress is better for back sleepers, Puffy or Saatva?

Both Puffy and Saatva are suitable for back sleepers. However, Saatva’s firmer feel and innerspring coils provide more support for the spine, making it a better option for those who need additional lumbar support.

Is the Puffy mattress good for people with back pain?

Yes, the Puffy mattress is an excellent option for people with back pain. Its soft foam layers contour to the body, relieving pressure points and providing targeted support where it’s needed most.

Is the Saatva mattress good for people with back pain?

Yes, the Saatva mattress is also a great choice for people with back pain. Its innerspring coils provide additional support for the spine, while its foam layers help cushion pressure points and reduce pain.

Which mattress sleeps cooler, Puffy or Saatva?

Saatva sleeps cooler than Puffy because of its innerspring coil system, which allows for better airflow and heat dissipation. Puffy, on the other hand, may retain more heat because of its all-foam construction.

Which mattress has better edge support, Puffy or Saatva?

Saatva has better edge support than Puffy because of its innerspring coil system. The coils provide additional support around the perimeter of the mattress, making it easier to sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’re going to roll off.

Is the Puffy mattress good for couples?

Yes, the Puffy mattress is a great option for couples. Its all-foam construction minimizes motion transfer, which means you won’t feel your partner moving around in bed. It’s also available in multiple sizes to accommodate different sleeping arrangements.

Is the Saatva mattress good for couples?

Yes, the Saatva mattress is also an excellent option for couples. Its innerspring coil system helps reduce motion transfer, making it easier to sleep with a partner. Plus, it’s available in multiple sizes and firmness levels to suit different preferences.

Which mattress is better for value, Puffy or Saatva?

Both Puffy and Saatva are excellent value mattresses, but Saatva is generally considered the better option. It offers more features and options, including multiple firmness levels, an innerspring coil system, and a longer trial period, all at a similar price point to Puffy.

About Perry Morris

Perry Morris is a freelance writer, columnist, and mattress expert who contributes content for online publications such as New Mattress Time.